After a couple of emails back and forth with support, got a solution that worked.
Unplugged the keyboard, went into my Mac's Audio Midi Setup, deleted the Arturia device that was there, plugged it back in. Then in Logic everything was able to be set up the way it should be.
Oddly enough, plugged in another device (not same brand) but had similar problem. Did the same thing and it worked again too.
A shout out to Arturia support for all the help.